I’ve been thinking a lot about America lately. That’s a dangerous way to start a conversation these days, especially where I live in North Idaho. Somebody is bound to assume I’m about to explain why their political party is ruining the country. I have my opinions, of course. But I’ve spent enough time arguing about what’s wrong to wonder how much thought I’m giving to what I want us to do next.
This past week, Americans went to the polls. Democrats won enough seats to take control of Congress in January, and there will be plenty of analysis about how it happened and what it means. I’m interested in those conversations. I also hope we spend some time asking what people ought to expect from the government they’ve elected, beyond the satisfaction of seeing their side win.
I listened to James Talarico speaking in Texas about loving your neighbor, including the neighbor who voted differently. I paid attention to Abdul El-Sayed’s message about making government work for ordinary people. Those are things I want to hear more about. I’d like to believe we’re reaching a point where Americans are ready to expect something better from the people who represent us. Good Lord, I think we’re getting tired.
We’ve heard “Make America Great Again” so many times that it’s difficult to hear the words without immediately thinking about the politics attached to them. I’d like to take them seriously for a minute. You want to make America great? I’m interested. Tell me what that would look like in the lives of the people who live here.
I love this country. I value the freedom to disagree, including with the people running it. People from completely different backgrounds have built extraordinary things here, and I believe we still have an enormous capacity to do good. Loving America also gives me plenty of reasons to be frustrated with what we’ve come to accept.
I work in healthcare. I see what happens when people struggle to get the help they need. I know families who have carried enormous burdens through illness and loss, trying to manage circumstances they never expected. When I think about a better America, I think about whether a family facing a serious illness would also have to worry about losing everything financially. I think about young people having a reasonable chance at a good future. Those concerns feel more useful to me than another argument about who loves the country most.
We have resources and people with the ability to help solve these problems. We also have serious disagreements about how to do it. Healthcare alone will give you enough of those to fill several lifetimes. I want us to have those arguments and do the difficult work of figuring things out. I have a harder time accepting that another ten years of calling each other names is the best we have to offer.
Open your phone and, within a few minutes, somebody will tell you what you ought to be furious about. A politician said something outrageous. A stranger behaved terribly. A commentator has an explanation for why the other half of the country is responsible for everything that’s wrong. There’s always something, and I’ve given plenty of it my attention.
I’ve posted things when I was irritated. I’ve watched arguments unfold online and wondered how people arrived at such different versions of reality. I’ve spent far too much time thinking about somebody else’s ridiculous opinion. I’m entitled to disagree with them. I’m less sure why I needed to give them so much of my day. None of that made me particularly useful to anyone.
One thing I’ve learned through years of leadership is that the attitude I bring into a room affects what happens there. If I walk into a difficult meeting convinced that everyone will be unreasonable, I’ve made the situation harder before anyone says a word. When I’m willing to listen and consider what I might be missing, we have a better chance of getting somewhere. It doesn’t guarantee a happy ending. I wish it did. But I’ve seen enough difficult situations to know that my own behavior belongs in the conversation about what needs to change.
For years, I’ve been interested in optimism, the law of attraction, and the idea that the energy we carry affects the world around us. Some people approach that spiritually. Others understand it through psychology and behavior. I’m interested in both, although I get uncomfortable when those ideas become a way to blame people for their suffering. I’ve watched wonderful people endure things nobody deserves. I don’t believe they brought those hardships upon themselves by thinking the wrong thoughts.
I do believe our expectations influence how we behave. If I expect nothing good from a conversation, I’m less likely to give it much of a chance. If I believe an effort is worth making, I’m more likely to participate. That leaves me wondering what we’re missing while so much of our attention goes to the things we fear and the people who irritate us.
I want to be careful here, because asking people to come together is easier when you haven’t borne the consequences of the policies being debated. Political decisions have affected people’s healthcare, their safety, and whether they feel welcome in their own communities. Those experiences deserve to be heard. I don’t want an appeal to optimism to become another reason someone is told to stop making people uncomfortable.
A hopeful America still needs people willing to challenge harmful policies and hold powerful institutions accountable. There are things worth standing firmly against, even when doing so makes a conversation difficult. And sometimes the most loving thing you do is tell somebody they’re behaving like an asshole. Respecting another person doesn’t relieve either of you of responsibility for what you say and do.
I’ve always appreciated people who believe strongly enough in something to disagree with me and respect me enough to keep talking. That requires some humility on my part, too. I’ve been wrong before. I’m fairly certain I’ll manage it again. I’d like to leave other people some room to reconsider what they believe, especially if I hope they’ll give me the same courtesy.
These questions are part of why I recently started exploring an idea for another book. The working title is What We Build Next: A New American Optimism. I keep thinking about how thoroughly we’ve discussed everything we don’t want, while the question of what we hope to build often gets much less of our attention.
I’ve spent a lot of my life building things with other people, including healthcare organizations and community partnerships. I’ve worked on creative projects and invested in relationships that have lasted through difficult years. Some efforts worked. Others taught me lessons I would have preferred to learn a less expensive way. The experiences that have stayed with me involved people who believed something was worth doing and were willing to help, even without any certainty about how it would turn out.
There are people doing that work across this country every day. They care for patients and teach our kids. They help a neighbor through a difficult stretch or keep showing up for their families while carrying problems of their own. Most of their work won’t become a national conversation. I think about how much attention we give to someone behaving terribly, compared with how little we give to the people we depend on. I’d like to pay closer attention to what those people understand about being useful.
I want more from our leaders, and I think it’s fair to ask more of ourselves. I think about the country my children will live in and the conversations I hope they’ll have with people who see things differently. Then I have to consider whether the way I’m conducting myself has much to do with that hope.
Some days, I’m tired and irritated and would prefer everyone leave me alone for a while. I don’t always listen as well as I should. I get caught up in the same arguments I’m writing about here. Optimism matters to me partly because I need a reason to try again after those days. I still believe there are things worth working toward, even with plenty of evidence that the work will be difficult.
America has spent years arguing about what we’re against. It’s time to get serious about what we’re for.
So I’d like you to spend a little time with this question: What do you want America to be like for the people you love? Think about your family, your neighbors, and someone whose life is different from yours. What would you hope they could count on? What would you be willing to help make possible?
Then bring it down to something you have some say over. There might be a conversation you’ve been avoiding, a community effort you’ve been meaning to join, or a person who deserves more patience than you’ve been giving them. Choose one thing you’d do differently this week, and hit reply to tell me about it. I’m interested in the small, specific answer you’d actually follow through on.
If this gives you something worth talking about, share it with someone you’d like to have that conversation with. You don’t have to agree with everything I’ve written. Tell me what you think I’m missing, too. I’d like to hear what you hope we build next, and where you’re willing to help.
Mike Baker
Just an Ordinary Tuesday | Notes from a life I’m still trying to pay attention to.